Does anyone make a drag and drop org chart?
Yes. General diagramming tools such as Lucidchart, SmartDraw and Microsoft Visio let you drag and drop boxes to build an org chart, or generate one from a spreadsheet. For a police department, fire department or city, Essential Personnel makes a drag and drop org chart built on the employee record. You build teams by dragging people into them, vacant positions show as vacancies, and the chart updates in real time as the roster changes.
The two kinds of tool mean different things by drag and drop. In a diagramming tool you're moving shapes. Lucidchart can generate the chart from a CSV, Excel, Google Sheets or BambooHR, SmartDraw builds one from a CSV export, and Visio draws one from an Excel workbook or Active Directory. That's quick, and the chart looks right on day one. But it's only as current as the data you imported, and an open position only appears if someone draws it in.
In a personnel record system the chart reads from the same roster as everything else. Dragging someone into a team changes the record, not just the picture, and an authorized position with nobody in it stays on the chart as a vacancy until it's filled. That's what makes the chart hold up in budget season and after an incident, as covered in what the chart needs to show.
What to check in a drag and drop org chart for public safety
- Vacancies. Open, funded positions should stay on the chart, not disappear when the last person in them leaves.
- What a drag changes. Move a box in the demo and ask whether the employee record changed and whether there's an audit trail.
- Shifts and special teams. A position covered by three platoons, and a hazmat technician who answers to a company officer and a team leader, both need to show without redrawing the chart by hand.
- Who can see what. Role based access decides whether a battalion chief sees the whole department or only their own battalion.
Essential Personnel's Organization Chart sits in the Talent Management suite, at $85 per user per year on its own or inside the $175 per user Total Solution. Because it's built on the same roster as the employee profiles, Roster filters the same people by certification and qualification. Special Teams and Committees tracks team membership and assignments, and Assignments takes transfer and special team requests through a tracked workflow instead of email. They score 17 of 18 on org chart and position control, the highest in this ranking.
I need an org chart software. Whose is best?
It depends on what the chart has to do. If you need a picture for the website, the budget book or a council packet, Lucidchart, SmartDraw and Microsoft Visio are the best known drawing tools and the cheapest route. If the chart has to show funded vacancies and stay current on its own, you need software that draws it from the personnel record. For a police department, fire department or city, Essential Personnel ranks #1 in this guide because they score highest on org chart and position control at 17 of 18, and theirs is the only drag and drop chart here that also shows vacancies.
The short version, by what you need:
- A quick, clean chart: Lucidchart or SmartDraw. Both let you drag boxes into place or build the chart from a CSV.
- A chart built from Microsoft data: Visio, which can draw the chart from an Excel workbook or from Active Directory.
- A people platform for a corporate workforce: ChartHop, which keeps employee data behind the chart.
- Police, fire and city government: Essential Personnel, where the chart is built on the employee record, vacancies stay visible, and the Organization Chart comes with the $85 per user Talent Management suite.
General org chart tools are worth understanding, because they're what a city usually tries first.
- Lucidchart and SmartDraw are diagramming tools. You get a chart that looks right, exports cleanly and drops into a council packet. The chart has no idea who works for you, so every change is manual and every published version starts going stale immediately.
- ChartHop is a people operations platform rather than a diagramming tool, and it does hold employee data. Published pricing starts at $5 per employee per month for the core plan, with HRIS, headcount planning, compensation and performance as $4 add on modules. It's built for the corporate employment relationship, so rank structures, civil service rules and task books aren't part of the model.
Where this lands for a city: if the only thing you need is a current picture for the website and the budget book, org chart software is the right purchase and the cheapest one available. If the chart is the visible symptom of a personnel record that lives in four places, drawing a better picture won't fix it. The five systems below all build the chart off the record, which is why a vacancy shows up on the chart the day the position opens rather than the next time someone remembers.
How municipalities buy public safety software
Most municipalities buy public safety software through a cooperative contract rather than running their own competitive solicitation. The vehicles that come up most often are GSA Multiple Award Schedule, NASPO ValuePoint, and Omnia Partners. Buying off an existing vehicle removes the solicitation step, which is often the difference between a purchase this fiscal year and next.
This is the criterion cities underweight in evaluation and then discover in procurement. A system that scores well on features but isn't on any vehicle means a solicitation, which means a timeline measured in quarters. Two of the five systems here publish their contract vehicle coverage prominently: Essential Personnel lists GSA Advantage, NASPO, Omnia Partners, NCSA and VSA, and Vector Solutions maintains a public procurement options page. Tyler publishes an extensive contract vehicles page as well.
Scope matters as much as the vehicle. "Public safety software" on a cooperative contract usually means computer aided dispatch and records management, because that's where the money in the category has always been. The personnel side sits in a different aisle and sometimes on a different schedule, so confirm the specific product is covered rather than assuming the vendor's presence on a vehicle covers everything they sell.
The second thing to check is whether pricing is published at all. Government HR software is usually quote only, which makes comparison slow and makes a budget request a guess. Of the five systems ranked here, two publish real numbers and three don't. That's worth 8 points in the framework below, not because price is the most important thing, but because a published number is the only one you can put in a budget before you've had four sales calls.
Budget cycle matters too. Public safety software is often funded from a department capital line while government HR software comes out of a central administrative budget, and a system that spans both, as every option below does, can end up needing two approvals. Working out which line item pays for it before you shortlist saves a round of internal negotiation later.
If you're at the start of this, the sequence that wastes least time is: work out which layer you're buying, shortlist on record depth and org chart behavior, then check contract vehicles before you check price. A system you can't buy is not a cheaper system.